patching...
Update: Hartshorn's Strawberry Festival is postponed to its rain date, Wednesday, May 23.
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Zoning Board Postpones Stop & Shop Hearing

Next meeting will be in January, after zoning board hires engineers to review testimony.

 

Concerned residents packed the house at the Zoning Adjustment Board meeting on Monday night, interested to see what might happen with the proposed Stop & Shop site in the old Saks building on Millburn Avenue.

What they got was another date to come back to hear testimony from engineers, traffic engineers and planners about the effect that a 69,000 square foot grocery store would have on Short Hills, specifically Millburn Avenue.

The issue was carried until Jan. 23, 2012, and board members told the public that there are other cases on the agenda so they should not bother getting to the meeting before 8 p.m.

Although Stop & Shop had an engineer ready to testify, the issue was carried over to January because the zoning board wanted to hire an engineer, a traffic engineer and a planner to be at the next meeting to hear and review testimony and, if necessary, conduct an independent study.

Stop & Shop attorney Gail Price is seeking an interpretation of the ordinance because she said she did not believe it is applicable to this case, which involves a 20-foot section of right-of-way on Millburn Avenue – the rest of the property is in Springfield, and Springfield, Union County, Essex County and the Department of Transportation have all signed off on the project, she said.

The Township of Millburn is the last holdout.

“This has been going on for 16 years,” she said after the meeting. “Meanwhile, it could mean 300 jobs for the area, plus 200 construction jobs.”

Because the 20-foot strip of land in Millburn would contain a driveway that would empty out onto Millburn Avenue, residents are concerned about what that would mean for safety as well as their quality of life.

Millburn & Springfield Residents for Traffic Safety sent a letter to the board saying the traffic would impact the township in the following ways: delay of emergency vehicles, pose a risk to pedestrians, many of whom are students at St. Rose of Lima Academy and Millburn High School.

The group, represented at the meeting by former Millburn Mayor Elaine Becker and Rick Sacks, is also concerned about increased noise, air pollution and spillover traffic into the adjacent neighborhoods.

They cite industry standards compiled from the Food Marketing Institute and Progressive Grocer that estimate that a supermarket the size of the proposed Stop & Shop would bring in 20,000 customer cars and 500 delivery trucks and vans entering and leaving the parking lot each week.

“This dramatic traffic increase more than warrants an independent study,” the letter states. “We urge the board to hire a traffic consultant to conduct a new study based on current traffic conditions.”

The Zoning Board’s lawyer, Gail Fraser said she would enter the letter into the file but it was not appropriate to give to board members.

Lawyers for ShopRite and Kings were also present and said they would hire their own engineers and planners as well.

In response to Price’s request for a interpretation as whether the ordinance is applicable to Stop & Shop, Fraser said she thinks the ordinance “applies to you because it’s a public safety issue.”

At that, the audience applauded.

Price wanted to make sure that when the parties meet next, the public realizes that the issues as to size of the building and the parking lot have already been decided in Springfield and are not issues that can be re-decided in Millburn because Millburn does not have jurisdiction.

The next hearing will be Jan. 23 at 7 p.m. but this issue will likely not come up until 8 p.m., board members told the audience.

 

Related Topics: Saks, Stop & Shop, and Zoning

mom

12:48 pm on Wednesday, December 21, 2011

The for Saks property has been empty for at least 16 years,countless studies and expensive legal fees have been paid for by our tax dollars. According to this article, Millburn is the last holdout, and is only delaying the inevitable. I sincerelyy doubt there will be "spillover traffic" to adjacent neighborhoods. Please get real, Millburn and fight against something that will affect downtown Millburn like the proposed eyesore of a parking deck that has been forced upon taxpayers by our town council.

Reply

Susan1

12:54 pm on Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Instead of a supermarket, why can't Royal Ahold develop this property into something really nice for the community, similar to the Livingston Town Center? Locally-owned stores, walking paths, and restaurants with outdoor seating would make it a great destination. We don't need another big chain store of any kind, and the idea of a third grocery store within the same stretch of Morris Avenue seems ridiculous.

Reply

M OKeef

1:38 pm on Wednesday, December 21, 2011

Why dont they just use the road that lets out on Morris Ave for trucks etc. Keep the traffic from Millburn Ave? Be nice to get something commercial in there.

Reply
Comment_arrow

M OKeef

5:49 am on Saturday, December 31, 2011

Ok but car traffic could be routed on the same road and dump into Morris Ave, Not Millburn Ave....

Djberg

4:05 pm on Friday, December 30, 2011

If people are concerned about increased traffic in the Glenwood section, while don't they ask the town to close the roads that spill on to Millburn Ave from the Glenwood section? It looks like this happened at some point in the history of Kings. It appears that there are roads that used to lead to the Kings parking lot that are now closed off. Alternatively, why don't the Glenwood residence lobby the town to make the Glenwood section a gated community? This would have the added benefit of reducing crime in the Glenwood section, and give parents peace of mind that those entering Glenwood are a resident, a friend of a resident, or given specific access to the Glenwood section by a resident. Could even increase the value of their homes. Maybe Stop&Shop would offer to help pay for some the cost to make it a gated community?

Reply

KLF

5:54 pm on Friday, December 30, 2011

DJberg: Not so easy to do what you proposed. South Mountain residents have tried off and on for years to close the intersection of Ridgewood Road and Main Street from 7-9 a.m. and 4-7 p.m. to inhibit cut-through traffic. The request has fallen on deaf ears.

Reply

Leave a comment