.

Women Warn of Short Hills Dog Attacks

Two dogs were attacked on the same day by dogs that have attacked before; court date set in February.

Until a few weeks ago, neighbors Allison Katz and Beth Silverberg didn’t know each other. They may have passed each other on the streets of their Short Hills neighborhood while walking their dogs, but can’t really be sure.

But then one recent Friday, they both experienced traumatic events with their dogs, and their paths crossed at the Millburn Veterinary Hospital.

On Jan. 6 both woman had walked their dogs on Deer Path in Short Hills when out of nowhere came a large brown dog that attacked their little "toy" dogs.

“It was horrific,” said Katz, whose dog Maggie, a 8-month-old Havanese puppy, was bitten so severely that she suffered a punctured lung and had to have emergency surgery.

Katz said she was just a couple of houses away from home on their walk when out of nowhere two dogs came charging toward them. “I thought there must be an invisible fence but nothing stopped them.”

Katz herself suffered bruises and a bite wound, although she doesn’t remember getting bitten as she frantically kicked the dogs away from Maggie and then scooped her up, went home, got her daughter and they took the dog to the vet.

“The entire way there the dog was crying and screaming; she was in so much pain,” she said.

At the hospital, the staff said it was the second attacked dog they’d had that afternoon.

In fact, Beth Silverberg was still at the vet with her dog, Bentley. She had lived through a similarly harrowing experience about an hour earlier.

The vet examined Maggie and sent Katz to an emergency veterinary hospital in Bloomfield that could handle such a trauma.

Because her daughter had to be elsewhere, she called her mother to come pick her up. She would stay at the vet’s while Katz took Maggie to Bloomfield.

“I didn’t even know Beth but she said she’d stay with Lauren until my mom got there,” she said.

Beth Silverberg was still shaken from her own incident with her Maltese but had had time to calm down, and said she could tell Katz needed to know that her daughter would be looked after while she waited.

Silverberg recalled her incident as “harrowing” but because only one of the dogs attacked her dog and because she was with a friend, they were able to get the dog pulled off her little Maltese a little more quickly.

“He looked friendly, and he came over slowly. Then all of sudden he leapt at Bentley and just attacked him,” she said.

Since then, both women, who used to walk their dogs everyday are nervous to take their dogs out for a walk in their own neighborhood.

“I will not go out without a weapon,” Silverberg said.

They both filled out police reports and filed charges and are now working to get some laws in Millburn changed. They’ve been told there’s not much that can be done until after the case goes to court and a judge has decides what remedy there will be for the situation and the dogs.

The dogs belong to another neighbor that she has gotten to know for the first time as well and who was charged by police with allowing her dogs to "run at large." Katz said the prosecutor told her he might also charge her with keeping a vicious dog.

“She was very sorry, and she’s been very nice,” Katz said, adding that the owner sent her a check to cover veterinary costs, which were about $2,400. “But that doesn’t make me feel better about her dogs. She said her invisible fence had been broken since the [snow] storm. But these dogs apparently have a reputation. Animal Control was familiar with them.

“I don’t know why Animal Control can’t seem to do anything.The family should send them the to a farm or something. If not, I want them muzzled. I want the fence fixed. I want them kept inside. I am scared to go out.” She said.

Meanwhile, there’s a court case set for Feb. 21.

Millburn Police Chief Greg Weber said that the Animal Control officer is periodically driving by the dog owner’s house to see what is happening with the dogs.

Katz said the Animal Control Officer told her that the pet door is now blocked and there doesn’t appear to be any problems with the back fence anymore. Weber said there are flags up in the yard, but he's not sure if the invisible fence is fixed.

Chief Weber said dogs in question have lived in Short Hills for nine years and he knows of only one other incident involving them.

“They’ve not been a persistent problem,” said Weber, adding that one of the dogs is a pit bull the other is a mix.

As for impounding or muzzling the dogs or making the owner do anything else, the court makes those rulings, Weber said.

Katz and Silverberg said they have had to take the initiative to find out anything about the case, including that there was even a case and that there was a court date. Had the women not called the police repeatedly, they would not have even known there was a court case and a date.

“We’re the victims. We’re the witnesses,” Silverberg said. “Wouldn’t you think that they’d want our testimony? Shouldn’t we be able to tell the judge what a terrifying experience this was?”

While Silverberg’s dog has recently taken walks again, he is timid while he’s out and she refuses to go near the street were the attack took place.

Maggie is healing, but still unable to go out and Katz is not going to take her out until she knows for certain those dogs can't get out.

“She’s lucky she’s alive,” she said. “She's a tough little thing. Thank goodness we’re OK. I keep thinking, what if it had been my daughter who was out walking her? It’s so frightening.”

Joanne Smythe January 31, 2012 at 04:06 AM
Loyalty is not the concern Lucy, but rather, dogs that maim and kill people, such as pit bulls.
Joanne Smythe January 31, 2012 at 04:11 AM
Lucy, your falsely stating those dog killing statistics are "incorrect" does not make it so. I provided statistics to back up my statements, you did not; provide some statistics of your own, or admit you're wrong. Here is a video of a pit bull biting the arm of its owner (WARNING GRAPHIC) and it refuses to let go as the man bleeds profusely. The dog is actually wagging its tail, and will not release the man's wrist: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=69f_1327285704
Joanne Smythe January 31, 2012 at 04:18 AM
Meghan, your claim that the dog bite fatalities cited are "false" does not make it so. Here is yet another report from the pit bull haters at the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association: http://www.dogsbite.org/pdf/1979-1998-breeds-dogs-involved-in-fatal-human-attacks-us.pdf Note the chart on the second page, clearly illustrating that pit bulls account for the overwhelming majority of people killed by dogs.
Dawn Tarr January 31, 2012 at 03:48 PM
its NEVER the breed of dog that is the issue, its ALWAYS the owners. The zoo can have friggin Tigers and Lions and they arent all about the streets eating children and pets.. if the owner cannot be held accountable for the pets they have, they dont need to have them, period. To Ban a breed of animal is rediculous and the motives of Hitler. Those dogs need different owners , or at least a lesson in being more responsible.
Hedley January 31, 2012 at 03:57 PM
The Tigers and Lions aren't eating children because they are in a cage and can't get out. Would you be fine with Tigers and Lions roaming the streets? How about if your neighbor kept a tiger in their backyard. As long as they are nice neighbors that would be fine? While many dog owners are certainly the issue, there are clearly breeds of dogs that are far more likely to be aggressive than others. Enjoy your rottweiler. I'm sure the neighborhood kids would love it. Oh, and next time you are at the zoo, open the cage and let your children go play with the animals. I'm sure it will be fine.
Dawn Tarr January 31, 2012 at 04:01 PM
did you not read the post? i said, OWNERS RESPONSIBILITY.. if the dogs are prone to attacking, sounds to me like they need a KENNEL.. my kennel goes all the way around my house.. room to run, and they arent running LOOSE.. why are these dogs loose to begin with? isnt someone afraid they will be it by a car? ITS IRRESPONSIBLE PET OWNERS!
Dawn Tarr January 31, 2012 at 04:02 PM
in addition, i have a pit mix and prior to her i had a full blooded male pit bull, and BOTH dogs love children.. they play ball with them, sleep with them, and are the most loving pets. This breed has a bad rap thanks to idiot owners and they way they USE them. These dogs never wanted to be fighters .. they are born like every other living thing.. innocent.. its thanks to HUMANS and the way they handle things that they are the way they are.. and this thread is JUST LIKE THAT.. .. open your eyes and deal with the problem like adults. If you allow the ban of animals, whats next? Pets should only be allowed to RESPONSIBLE PEOPLE.. if those same people had CHILDREN, they would be throwing firecrackers at your dog ..
KLF January 31, 2012 at 04:30 PM
But these dogs DID attack.
KLF January 31, 2012 at 04:46 PM
Dog bites are reported by the doctors who treat the humans victims and by veterinarians. In addition, the Humane Society and the CDC keep statistics. I'm not thinking that these sources pick and choose which bites to report.
paula January 31, 2012 at 05:34 PM
http://www.ywgrossman.com/photoblog/?p=604
paula January 31, 2012 at 05:39 PM
http://www.news9.com/global/story.asp?s=9494086 heres some more, bet this family is happy they owned a pit
paula January 31, 2012 at 05:40 PM
http://www.denverpost.com/search/ci_4095627 this family too
paula January 31, 2012 at 05:41 PM
http://saveabull.com/2011/pit-bull-hero-pitbull-saves-family-in-fire/
paula January 31, 2012 at 05:46 PM
http://whatapittie.org/proud-history-pitbull.html they were good enough to help protect our country.
paula January 31, 2012 at 05:51 PM
http://pitbullregistry.com/PitBull%20History.htm
paula January 31, 2012 at 05:55 PM
http://www.badrap.org/monster-myths
Michelle January 31, 2012 at 06:45 PM
These are great sites Paula. Thanks for posting.
paula January 31, 2012 at 06:51 PM
http://www.animallaw.info/articles/arus56depaullrev1285.htm
Tami DErrico January 31, 2012 at 07:48 PM
Joanne, pitbulls were never bred to harm people. They were bred to fight other dogs, but any fighting dog that bit the handlers would instantly be put down. As a result, pitbulls have much more control over their aggression than most other breeds do. Pitbulls were also bred to be fantastic human companions and loyal family dogs. Their loyalty and devotion is the characteristic that unsavory human types take unfair advantage of when they train them for aggression/attacking. But note all along it is HUMANS that have created these dogs; HUMANS who have abused them for their own selfish, inhumane purposes. Yes, I am a pitbull owner & advocate, but I am also an elementary school teacher who cares greatly for the safety and well being of children. At the same time, I cannot condone - nor teach - the stereotyping and prejudice associated with all the pitbull media hype & hysteria. My TDI certified therapy pit, LuLu, accompanies me to school in the hopes that our next human generation will grow up and not be so quick to judge - dogs or people. Life is all about choices, and I choose not to live in ignorance or fear. Yes, it is a tragedy what happened to these two little dogs - but I do not blame the bigger dogs, I blame the humans who should have never left them alone outside in the first place.
Dawn Tarr January 31, 2012 at 08:52 PM
Bravo Paula
Susan1 January 31, 2012 at 09:03 PM
I should add that I agree with most of the posters here that good owners make for good dogs and bad ones make for poorly behaved/dangerous ones. But there are clearly breeds that are more likely to be dangerous than others and they should only be owned by people who are equipped and willing to deal with that increased responsibility.
paula February 01, 2012 at 12:09 AM
thank you to all of the pittie supporters! ohio and miami-dade county are over turning their ban on pit bulls!!!!! yay educate....dont discriminate!
Michelle February 01, 2012 at 12:23 AM
Such wonderful news Paula!!You know why they are being overturned? Because its been proven time and time again, that they DON'T work!! Thanks for posting the GREAT news!!
megan February 01, 2012 at 02:15 AM
Joanne, the problem with the link you posted is that it is grouping "Pit bull-type" dogs together -- that typically accounts for a variety of breeds, including but absolutely not limited to American Pit Bull Terriers, American Bulldogs, English Bull Dogs, Bull Terriers, Staffordshire Bull Terriers, and various other breeds derived from mastiff/terrier mixes, etc., including Boxers, Cane Corso, Dogue De Bordeaux, Dogo Argentino, Presa Canario, or mixes thereof. It's a bit unfair to group multiple breeds together, count the number of bites they've been involved it, and then compare that number to single-breed bites and attacks. In addition to that, so many dogs are misidentified as "Pit bull-type" dogs when they actually have no pit bull in them whatsoever, yet they are typically included in the "Pit bull-type" category because of the way they look. There has not been one good or reliable study that can be cited to discuss dog bites -- and the reality of that is because dog breeds are so often misidentified, so many mixed breed dogs resemble "Pit bull-type" dogs even when they have no pit bull in them, and because so many bites and attacks are not reported unless they are by a specific breed. In fact, there are a number of surveys done where people freely admit that they would NOT report a Lab or Chi biting them, but would report it if the dog was a "Pit bull-type" dog. So please, get off your high horse and try again next time.
megan February 01, 2012 at 02:16 AM
Susan, she didn't blame the victim, she blamed the dog's owner -- which is where the responsibility lies.
megan February 01, 2012 at 02:16 AM
Hedley, you are comparing dogs that have been domesticated for thousands of years to animals who have never been domesticated. Apples to oranges -- that makes you wrong!
megan February 01, 2012 at 02:17 AM
Isn't it wonderful what a community of advocates can do, against a minority of folks who know nothing about dogs and breeds?
BETH SILVERBERG February 02, 2012 at 07:20 PM
YOU ARE ALL MISSING THE POINT HERE!!! THIS DOG WAS NOT PROVOKED BY ANY THING, OR ANYONE WHAT SO EVER!!! THE DOG CAME WALKING DOWN THE STREE WITH NO LEASE OR OWNER IN SIGHT, WALKED UP TO THE FIRST SMALL DOG ON A LEASH AND ATTACKED WHICH BY THE WAY TOOK TWO WOMAN QUITE SOME TIME TO GET IT TO LET GO OF THE SMALL DOG HOURS LATER THE FIRST DOG ALONG WITH ANOTHER DOG OFF ITS LEASH ONCE AGAIN WITH NO OWNER CHARGED DOWN THE STREET AND ATTACKED THE SECOND SMALL DOG AND ITS OWNER!! THIS IS NOT ABOUT A CERTAIN BREED OF DOG AT ALL, ITS ABOUT THE OWNERS OF ANY DOGS TAKING RESPONSIBILITY FOR THEIR PETS . MAKING SURE THEY ARE KEPT INSIDE A GATE OR FENCE WHEN THEY ARE UNABLE TO WALK THEM OR JUST KEPT INSIDE, BUT CERTAINLY NOT ALLOWED TO WALK THE STREETS UNACCOMPANIED AND ALONE!!! WE ARE SIMPLY TRYING TO PROTECT OUR NEIGHBORHOODS SO THEY ARE SAFE TO ENJOY NOTHING MORE NOTHING LESS!!!!!
paula February 02, 2012 at 07:51 PM
Thank you Beth for putting the blame where it belongs, on the dog owners! NOT the breed! It is a shame what happened to you and your dog and of course to your neighbor and her dog as well! I am glad to hear that you are recovering well! It could all have been prevented if the other dog owners were more RESPONSIBLE. As a responsible Pit owner it makes me feel good that you, as the victim, don't blame the breed. Thank you.
chokhi February 17, 2012 at 02:37 PM
Ten Commandments of Pit Bull Ownership 1. Thou shalt NEVER trust thy Pit Bull not to fight 2. Thou shalt contain thy Pit Bull securely when not supervised by an adult 3. Thou shalt NEVER leave thy adult Pit Bull alone and unsupervised with another dog 4. Thou SHALT attend obedience classes most faithfully with thy Pit Bull 5. Thou SHALT keep thy Pit Bull socialized with ALL KINDS of people 6. Thy Pit Bull wilt NEVER be allowed off-leash in a public place 7. Thy Pit Bull wilt NEVER be allowed to roam free in thy neighborhood, EVER! 8. Thou SHALT take thy well trained Pit Bull out in public and show him/her off - on leash for good breed PR! 9. Thy Pit Bull shalt go forth into the world as an ambassador of the pit bull breed 10. THOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY WRONG DONE BY THY DOGS!

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something